Katy v Old Rosie. Girl Fight!

This week is a real hair-pulling fight, with a bit of nail-scratching, smudged makeup and a flash of knicker.Old Rosie v Katy

From Thatchers, in Somerset, we have Katy. Weighing in at 7.4%, this single variety drink claims to be made from the perfect cider apple.

And from Westons, Herefordshire, we have Old Rosie. A slightly lighter 7.3%, but this cloudy cider claims to be named after the Weston’s family steam roller from 1921.


It seems that many ciders are made from a mixture of cider apples, with funny, olde-worlde sounding names, like Foxwhelp, Hagloe Crab, Chibble’s Wilding…. However, Katy is made from only one. Guess which one.

It has a sharp taste, but a delicate floral smell, a bit like waking up in a west country hedgerow. You can smell the flowers, the little white ones on those big, umbrella stems, that people think of as weeds, and always reminds me of hayfever. As a dry cider, it also has that slight toilet-water taste. I’ve never drank toilet water, and don’t intend to confirm this similarity, but it’s a small that comes with many ciders, a sort of farmyard smell.

This cider would suit those with a palate for drier ciders.

Verdict 3/5

Old Rosie is a cloudy cider, a fact that sometimes puts people off, but is comforting to me that there are real apples in there. I immediately smelled that Rosie is a warmer, sweeter cider, more autumnal. That might be the oak vats it’s matured in. Rosie is heavy with apples, fruity, sweet and a little bit smoky, like, I imagine, the character of that old steam roller.

Today, experience beat strength and Old Rosie managed to grab Katy’s apron strings, got her in a headlock and gave her a Dutch rub (knuckles in the head), before they both set off to the farmhouse, to share a flagon of scrumpy, bake some bread and berate the husbands.

Verdict: 5/5

2 thoughts on “Katy v Old Rosie. Girl Fight!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s